Ah, Tony, Tony, Tony. After a night of somewhat lackluster celebration of Broadway’s best, I (guest commentator Rachel, that is) present the good, the bad, and the ugly from the 62nd Annual Tony Awards:
Good
Best Musical nominee Cry-Baby performing the best song and dance number from the show, “A Little Upset.”
Patti LuPone tearing down the house performing “Everything’s Coming Up Roses” from Gypsy. Not that there was any doubt that she would.
Best Direction of a Play winner Anna D. Shapiro’s acceptance speech, which was emotional, sincere, thankful, and even funny.
Richard Griffiths making an off-the-cuff Harry Potter joke while presenting the Best Play award with Daniel Radcliff.
The original cast of Rent joining together to honor the show, which is closing later this year. Love Rent, or hate Rent, there’s no denying the impact it’s had on theater or the chemistry the original cast has together.
Bad
Host Whoopi Goldberg letting Counting Crows’ Adam Duritz introduce the performance from Best Musical nominee Passing Strange because she “had to pee.” Urination humor, at the Tony’s? Show some class!
The cast of Grease giving a performance on par with a high school production of Grease. Yet they continue to charge Broadway ticket prices to go see it.
Ugly
Best Original Score winner Lin-Manuel Miranda performing an obviously well-rehearsed rap as his acceptance speech. Call me old fashioned, but I prefer the obviously humble and grateful weepy speeches from winners who weren’t expecting to win.
Musicals that weren’t good enough to be nominated still get to perform at the ceremony. Perhaps to prove to us that they really weren’t good enough to be nominated? Was anyone even questioning that?
You Decide
Goldberg’s multiple costume changes. I found them amusing and a fun way to liven up what has often been a kind of stuffy ceremony. But others might have found them cheesy and ridiculous (cheesy and ridiculous…at the Tony’s? Never!).



The cast of
My theater company,